Friday, October 3, 2014

The Destruction of Gotham

"The Destruction of Gotham" by Joaquin Miller is a very cruel and real story. The manner in which the characters are written gives credence to their believability in our reality. The passage we focused on was that of the newspaper reporter, the man who see the things that go on in the city.  In the passage the reporter is a spectator to everything that is occurring between the two young men, the lady, and the officer.  He witnessed as the officer stood by, took the bribe of the young man with no recourse, and watched him leave.  This fits into the plot of the story because it foreshadows things to come for the protagonist. The phrase "Saw a man and moster exchange glances; saw that all was well understood - this young man, this New Yorker, would deman and recieve of the old monster an account of her stewardship." (16) Is what sets up the whole story. It tells you that this young man, who has money, feels he can do anything with it. This includes claiming ownership over the beautiful young girl. This locks into a bigger idea that Miller has in this story, he writes "A course man of this city once remarked, with more force than grammer, 'That in New York a man can live as many lives as he has money.' Matherson now lived many lives, for he had much money"(37).  He is saying that a person who has money can get away with doing what they want, become who they want, and live however  they want. It ties back to the first passage, as he claims the girl and bribes the officer to stave him from trouble. Money is the one thing that lets him do whatever he wants. This comes back to the report, who from the shadows, is once again a witness to all that is happening to the poor girl.

3 comments:

  1. Your observation that in this story, those with money are above the law, is very accurate and sums up on the the main themes of the story. The image of Matherson exchanging glances with the old woman, and handing a bribe to the corrupt police officer really sums these themes up well. This really does foreshadow the violence that occurs later because when the law fails to uphold justice, the people are forced to take justice into their own hands.

    My questions now are,

    Are these themes repeated in Caesar's Column or May Day?
    When money is able to supersede the law, is violence the only answer?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that your themes here are corruption, and the unfair powers and privileges of rich people. These scenes that you describe definitely support these themes. I'm just curious to know if you think about these scenes in a different way now that you have finished the reading.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great observation and close reading Michael. When you mention, " The manner in which the characters are written gives credence to their believability in our reality." I was looking forward to hear your voice on that.

    Best,
    Brian Ramos

    ReplyDelete